The ObservatorySelf-esteem can't be talked into being
Mirror affirmations, praise and "you are amazing" never built anyone's self-esteem. What builds it is less glamorous — and doable.
For several decades a whole culture believed that self-esteem was the key to everything — and that it was built with praise, gold stars and positive affirmations in the mirror. School programs were launched, books sold by the million. Then the research counted.
The result was discouraging for the movement: high self-esteem turned out to be mostly a CONSEQUENCE of things going well — not a cause. Artificially pumping it up did not give better performance or behavior; in experiments where struggling students were given self-esteem-boosting encouragement, they did worse, not better. And affirmations in front of the mirror? Studies show that those who feel worst fare even worse when repeating "I am loved and capable" — the statement clashes with their self-image, and the clash wins.
That's the beginning. The rest of the article is part of Premium — try it free for 7 days, with no card.
The rest of the text and the exercise are part of Premium. You try everything for 7 days with no card, and can cancel whenever you like. Sign in if you already have an account.
Why does it work?
That self-esteem is mainly a consequence rather than a cause, and that artificially raising it does not improve outcomes, is the conclusion of the large review by Baumeister et al. (2003) and later experiments (Forsyth 2007). That positive affirmations can backfire for people with low self-esteem was shown by Wood et al. (2009). Sociometer theory is Leary's; the benefits of self-compassion are the research field of Neff.
Account, your first assessment with the hexagon and one new measurement every quarter are free. The rest is part of Premium: SEK 99 a month or SEK 699 a year, VAT included.
Read more
How is your self-esteem doing?
Six signs that reveal how your self-esteem is actually doing, beyond how it feels on a good day.
Exercise8 minThe me without the title
Two thought experiments that strip away roles and titles, one at a time, until what remains becomes clearer
Exercise13 minTry a new role
"I'm just like this" is a hypothesis, not a fact. Write a script for a different you, and play it in a single scene.