The ObservatoryRumination that pretends to be work
Replaying something feels like doing something about the problem — here is why it rarely is
You lie awake and replay the same scene for the ninth time. Why did I say that. What did they really think. How could I miss it. It doesn't feel like wasting time — it feels like working on the problem, almost like guarding it so it doesn't get forgotten before it's solved. That very feeling is why rumination is so hard to stop. The mind treats it as an open case, not as a way of feeling bad for no reason.
It is worth separating two things that are easily confused: reflecting and ruminating. Reflection moves — it gathers information, tries out an interpretation, lands on an insight or a decision and moves on. Rumination circles the same question without getting anywhere: the same why, again and again, never answered. The difference doesn't show from the outside — both can look like sitting and thinking. It shows in whether the train of thought actually leads somewhere.
That's the beginning. The rest of the article is part of Premium — try it free for 7 days, with no card.
The rest of the text and the exercise are part of Premium. You try everything for 7 days with no card, and can cancel whenever you like. Sign in if you already have an account.
Why does it work?
Susan Nolen-Hoeksema's research on rumination (response styles theory, from the 1990s onward) shows that people who ruminate on a setback tend to feel worse afterwards than people who distract themselves or act. Edward Watkins' research on abstract versus concrete processing shows that abstract "why" questions are associated with prolonged low mood, whereas concrete questions are more often adaptive.
Account, your first assessment with the hexagon and one new measurement every quarter are free. The rest is part of Premium: SEK 99 a month or SEK 699 a year, VAT included.
Read more
The worry log
A standing tool: catch the worry when it comes, sort out what you can influence, and park the rest for a set time instead of ruminating all day.
Exercise10 minWorry time
Stop worrying a little all day long. Gather the worry into one fixed, limited stretch of time and sort it there.
Exercise12 minPut the thought on trial
A painful thought often feels like a truth. Here you examine it, calmly and methodically.