The ObservatoryShame and guilt are not the same thing
Guilt says "I did something wrong" and can repair things. Shame says "I am wrong" and repairs nothing. The difference changes everything.
Two emotions that are often lumped together — but the research that pulled them apart found that they work almost like opposites.
Guilt is aimed at an action: I DID something wrong. It is uncomfortable in a useful way — it points at what happened, stirs the urge to set things right, and can be completed: apologize, repair, do it differently next time. People who readily feel guilt (but not shame) have, in studies, better relationships and take more responsibility. Guilt is morality's workhorse.
That's the beginning. The rest of the article is part of Premium — try it free for 7 days, with no card.
The rest of the text and the exercise are part of Premium. You try everything for 7 days with no card, and can cancel whenever you like. Sign in if you already have an account.
Why does it work?
The distinction between action and self, and the different outcomes — guilt linked to repair and better relationships, shame to avoidance and mental ill-health — is well established through Tangney's research program (Tangney & Dearing 2002). That shame diminishes when it is met with empathic sharing is central to Brown's research and consistent with Pennebaker's findings.
Account, your first assessment with the hexagon and one new measurement every quarter are free. The rest is part of Premium: SEK 99 a month or SEK 699 a year, VAT included.
Read more
How do you talk to yourself?
Six scales inspired by the three pairs of self-compassion: kindness versus self-criticism, connectedness versus isolation, presence versus rumination.
Exercise12 minThe inner boss
Meet the voice that talks to you at work — and teach it a kinder tone.
Exercise9 minThe good-enough day
For the days when not everything got done, and the chafing stays anyway.