Skip to content
Comdira
The Observatory
Article2 minSubjectiveRationality

Memory is not a recording

We trust our memories like video evidence. Research shows otherwise, and that has practical consequences for how you use yours.

It feels as if memory records: the event is there, and you press play. But decades of memory research have shown that the metaphor is fundamentally wrong. Memory doesn't play back; it RECREATES. Every time you remember something, the memory is assembled anew from fragments, expectations and everything you've learned since. And every time you put it back, it has changed a little.

How malleable it is surprised even the researchers. In famous experiments, a single carefully chosen word in a question, how fast were the cars going when they SMASHED into each other?, was enough to make witnesses remember broken glass that was never there. With a little help from instructions and repetition, participants have had whole childhood memories implanted: that they got lost in a shopping mall, or went up in a hot-air balloon. These were vivid, detailed, emotional memories of things that never happened. And the most unsettling finding: how CERTAIN you feel about a memory says surprisingly little about how accurate it is.

Try Premium

That's the beginning. The rest of the article is part of Premium — try it free for 7 days, with no card.

The rest of the text and the exercise are part of Premium. You try everything for 7 days with no card, and can cancel whenever you like. Sign in if you already have an account.

The evidence

Why does it work?

The reconstructive nature of memory, the effect of leading questions and implanted memories are the research field of Loftus (Loftus & Palmer 1974; Loftus 1995 and later); that subjective certainty is a weak indicator of accuracy is well replicated. Mood-congruent memory is documented (Bower). The warning against suggestive memory-digging is shared by professional guidelines.

Account, your first assessment with the hexagon and one new measurement every quarter are free. The rest is part of Premium: SEK 99 a month or SEK 699 a year, VAT included.

More places

Read more